WINGECARRIBEE Council has decided McDonald’s should become the new northern gateway to historic Moss Vale.
Following fierce debate at Wednesday night’s meeting, all but Councillors Larry Whipper and Jim Clark voted to change the land zoning of an adjacent residential block so that McDonald’s can build a drive-through restaurant on the corner of Suttor and Argyle Streets (where a former car yard is situated - pictured above).
A talk from McDonald’s Australia development manager Trevor Forster and subsequent Council discussion saw a change-of-mind from Mayor Duncan Gair, who abandoned Crs Whipper and Clark to vote for amending the draft Local Environment Plan.
This will effectively allow McDonald’s to use a residential block for commercial means.
Council will also help McDonald’s with its development application in terms of design, traffic, signage and layout issues.
Earlier, a Cr Whipper motion to refuse changes to the “freshly inked” LEP was defeated after only Crs Gair and Clark offered their support.
Cr Ken Halstead was “deadly opposed”, saying McDonald’s was a responsible company that employed young people.
“Moss Vale needs stimulous and this is a sterile site... any developer would have a problem with traffic,” he said. “I don’t see a problem with this development at all.”
Cr Whipper wanted Council to help McDonald’s find an alternative position in Moss Vale, arguing that community safety was being compromised by the amount of traffic on nearby roads, which would increase once a connection to the enterprise zone had been finalised.
He believed that changing the new draft LEP at the first challenge showed scant regard for the large amount of work Council staff had put into detailing it.
“We are rewriting the destiny of Moss Vale... and will end up with an entry to the town marked by a golden ‘M’,” Cr Whipper said.
“Why go through the process of planning if we are going to throw it out the window. I thought we took our planning responsibility seriously? I think we’ve bent over forwards [for McDonald’s].”
Cr Clark sparked a furious response when he questioned Council’s planning resolve.
“Here we are at the first hurdle and we’ve rolled over. McDonald’s is doing our strategic planning for us and our staff may want to know why we’ve gone against their recommendations,” he said.
Cr Jim Mauger said he took umbrage at the comment and demanded to know what sites would be better than the one preferred by McDonald’s, while Cr David Stranger said the “sterile” vacant lot would be a “monument to this Council” if they knocked back development.
Mr Forster, who hinted that the new restaurant could be operated by Sutton Forest McDonald’s owner Graham Marcolin, said McDonald’s had already taken their amended plans to the RTA, which had initially raised traffic and safety concerns, and that the RTA had responded favourably to a new design and layout.
But it all hinged on McDonald’s being able to persuade Council to change the Wingecarribee LEP from residential to commercial on a residential block next to the corner site.
Cr Whipper was worried that other corporations might use this decision as a platform to demand changes to the LEP to accommodate their enterprises.
He also insisted that pedestrians and motorists would be at greater risk with a McDonald’s operating from that site.
“This is not McDonald’s bashing, this is a concern for community safety... and I agree with the conclusion of [Council] staff that this is not the way to do it,” he said.
“I’m a little perplexed. The ink hasn’t dried on the LEP and suddenly here’s McDonald’s leading the charge. Nobody’s saying we don’t want McDonald’s in Moss Vale. Nobody’s depriving any young person of jobs. This is working for the community’s best interest.”
Cr Clark was not suprised McDonald’s had set their sights on that particular site, given its location and amount of passing traffic, but wondered whether it was appropriate to do a spot rezoning to try and “fit a square peg into a round hole”.
“It’s not as if McDonald’s is the only business the site could be used for,” he said.
Mayor Duncan Gair said McDonald’s had not yet lodged a development application for the site.
“Council will work with McDonald’s to meet all requirements of the site,” he said.
Cr Whipper said Council had voted to extend the commercial precinct of Moss Vale beyond the borders of the new LEP.